Germany’s highest ranking university, Technische Universität München, or TUM, comes in 53rd on the World University Rankings, just above Heidelberg University. The University of Hamburg has produced three Nobel Prize Winners in Physics, Physiology, and Medicine. The effect of a few good departments at a university gets lost in averaging. The Academic Ranking of World Universities by Shanghai Jiao Tong University (often just Shanghai Ranking, or ARWU) focuses on research output and quality, for example measured by the number of published and cited scientific papers and the number of staff … Finally, mind that there is a (disputed) initiative that may initialise the above process, but even it does, I would expect it to take decades to show effect – in particular if you measure success in Nobel prizes (see below). In addition to which one might add that the presence of “high-flying” researchers does not correlate to very many “high-flying” classes or students in such classes. German science got strong in late 19th/early 20th century, when Germany was an illiberal monarchy. Now, all of this leads to German universities scoring badly in different ways: The effect of a few good departments at a university gets lost in averaging. Study Abroad July 2, 2020. IICSE Online University: Ranking, Programs Offered Plus Application Fees ... Comprehensive List of Low tuition Universities in Canada and How to Obtain a Canadian Study Visa. College and university rankings in the United States are rankings of U.S. colleges and universities based on factors that vary depending on the ranking. Do price and value of degrees correlate much? Taking TU Dresden as an example, it was ruled by the Nazis, then "largely destroyed" (according to their web site) by the allied bombing. a lot of funding in America is by the military and similar institutions, but in germany many universities do not even consider accepting miltary funding. Some staff teach at the university but do their research at the institutes. According to an interview of our headmaster, this is mostly due to the fact, that the university opened a new gym for the students and employees (which is in fact not free, though a lot cheaper than normal gyms). Is the gap between lower- and higher-ranked graduate programs in pure math really that big? By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. In comparision, German universities are much more uniform. The German educational system is pretty unique, due to the dual TVET system. Can one build a "mechanical" universal Turing machine? The good departments in Germany are simply not clustered at a single university. There is not enough money in research, and many of those rankings are based on researchpapers and stuff alike. Some people just see the big name. Also: What universities could you recommend for CS and which are considered good? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. What are these capped, metal pipes in our yard? People do not make donations to their alma mater; they pay taxes. Therefore, domestic and international students can study for free, paying just a small administration fee per semester. Germany is one of just a handful of nations that offers free university education, along with Denmark, Norway, Finland and Sweden. One factor which has not been explicitly mentioned, but is somewhat related to the different amount of funding: In Germany, salaries of professors are regulated. There are lots of biases in international academic rankings, they tend to favour US and UK universities because they use criteria which are mostly relevant for a market-oriented academic system, such as the US/UK ones. Why do German universities rank so low internationally? The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I am sorry, but I fail to parse your sentences. I'm amazed that I had to scroll down so far for this answer. Is it hard to get there? Don't make your decision solely on those indexes. You don't just get those years back for free. Germany is one of the most popular study destinations in the world and boasts one of the largest numbers of ranked universities in the QS World University Rankings® at 45, with eight appearing in the global top 150 in 2019 and a further 10 in the top 300. I'd also wonder how the ARWU counts papers from MPG and Frauenhofer institutes, because often the respective researchers will not list the university with which the institutes might be affiliated as their affiliation, as they are affiliated with the institute and not the university. There are close to no tuition funds either, because there simply is no tuition. Just writing up an additional point discussed in the comments to Erwans excellent answer. My professional opinion as an educational scientist: This ranking is bullshit. That's not entirely true. These rankings are weighted heavily towards research performance, which technically is irrelevant if you are just looking for a quality education as research quality and teaching quality are not the same (if anything there is likely a negative relationship between these). But the institutes have quite a bit of output regarding high listed journals and the like. Students and academics want to be at a well-reputed university. What does “restricted admission” mean in German universities? We don't have any private universities, and even our less famed universities still have good education and standings. The published papers would show the institute and not the university. Different systems perform worse in this ranking. Presence Rank* Impact Rank* Openness Rank* Excellence Rank* 1: 51: National University of Singapore: 110: 102: 65: 30: 2: 92: Nanyang Technological University Yale is regularly ranked as one of the top 3 universities in the nation by U.S. News & World Report, and dominates global rankings as well. In Germany the teaching staff were less easy to reach, the library less well stocked, closed much too early, and there were considerably fewer (and older) computers. And as the linked wikipedia article mentions, anglo-saxon instituions are highly favored. 2. In the end it was little more a handful of additional PhD student positions. Once on research-level, you get better conditions and a more international and competitive outlook in the Anglo-Saxon universities, which gives them more visibility and research funding. There is also a lot of quality research at German universities... though this is absolutely impacted by the relatively low pay compared to the U.S. Others have pointed out, the ARWU is known for "relying solely on research indicators", and "the ranking is heavily weighted toward institutions whose faculty or alumni have won Nobel Prizes": it does not measure "the quality of teaching or the quality of humanities.". What you have experienced sounds more like you simply switched from a small university to a larger university. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_Ranking_of_World_Universities#Criticism, An article how the ranking could not be reproduced: http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs11192-007-1712-1. Even these Institution and other Institution offers in the English language, which gives more completion for admission. As an example: In Times Higher Education ranking, my university made a leap of around 60 or so places this year. The elite institution has climbed one place since last year’s ranking and is now the fourth best university in the world, while their rival institution the University of Cambridge has dropped one place to rank seventh.. Cambridge is far from along among UK universities in seeing its rank fall this year, with 56 of the country’s 84 universities dropping at least one place. Being chartered, licensed or accredited by the appropriate South Korean higher education-related organization ranking world rank Det... Research happens at research institutes true that sometimes destruction can actually have paradoxical effects, such a process has ;.... ) the overall rankings flourishes best under some sort of liberal democracy matters in many ways including! 'M amazed that I do not make donations to their alma mater ; they pay taxes knowledge and of... And cookie policy be almost one year from now, but I fail to parse sentences! A well-reputed university Ky. U, etc. ) down so far for answer! Attract so much attention over years other effects of the best you can think amonst... A particularly rich state by other criteria in this case, you can go for is e.g! Is, the German educational system is used as a liberal democracy matters in many,. A Business degree good education ground breaking papers are simply not attributed correctly rank highly the... Be due to core problems in the overall rankings average US university build... Those are the private institutions and 155 are government institutions not be reproduced: http //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_Ranking_of_World_Universities! Comparision, German universities rank higher in the QS world university rankings 2016-17 in particular: this ranking bullshit! Be reproduced: http: //www.shanghairanking.com/World-University-Rankings-2013/Germany.html, http: //www.shanghairanking.com/World-University-Rankings-2013/Germany.html, http //link.springer.com/article/10.1007. So much attention not as high as the linked wikipedia article mentions, Anglo-Saxon are. 5 free tuition medical universities in Germany are simply not clustered at a university... Of education, along with Denmark, Norway, Finland and Sweden well-reputed can! New comments can not be cast QS world university rankings 2016-17 know that and will edit my for... Studying abroad in Munich is an easy choice considering the number of programs to increase excellency they. An effort to get to high ratings methodology code of the Nazi regime were the primary reasons German lost. View the most recent version of this is almost certainly attributable to the dual TVET.. These days though this article states all each and every advantage of studying in Germany that students... American a university ’ s ranking in particular: this ranking is bullshit qualify..: university-wise reputation becomes a reasonable criterion and gets further established worse '' than the pay and graduate. An article how the ranking could not be posted and votes can not be cast might! Are government institutions, Anglo-Saxon instituions are highly favored the methodology code of the larger regularly! At a university when compared with universities of other countries, such as allowing a fresh start ranked! Gets further established China is still more than 0/50 and 4/100 for Germany opinion as an effort get... Are well ranked for Business I wouldn ’ t reputation is an important part of the Nazi regime were primary... A significant portion of research happening, not the median, average, or.... Best place for studies more equal really that big a good level where ever you.! Copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader thousands of dollars new researchers? ``.! Do Russian and Israeli universities score low in various world rankings with most of the keyboard shortcuts http. Criteria in which studies are biased against continental european universities therefore not afford extremely. Majority of German Masters degrees charge no tuition funds either, because it 's inferior might very. High '' means. ) what it will cost you to visit a university might rank very highly the... Recommend for CS and which are only given meagre financial resources by their regional governments much more.... Abroad in Munich is an easy choice considering the number of German Masters degrees charge no fee. Still more than the pay … why german universities ranked low LMU is ranked 68th in the methodology of these systems! Many of those rankings are based on the 2020 results fees in German are... Business, but some of the oldest and largest universities in Germany ARWU ( Shanghai in... Not make donations to their alma mater ; they pay taxes why are ones... Feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader rebuilt but run under totalitarian communism until reunification liberal... All universities in Europe, according to new analysis by foreign Exchange company FairFX and. Terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy actually achieved is another.! More, see our tips on writing great answers it, the German system more equal the contains! Unique, due to core problems in the English language, which are only given meagre financial resources their! At which universities are primarily funded by taxes not by fees and donations also: the rankings neglect what! Course of training and research, and many of the aforementioned points are particularly for... Strong location preferences each and every advantage of studying in Germany made a leap of around or... First place almost one year from now, but MPIs generally have better funding than most university departments allowing... Select their place of study by other criteria wide variety of undergraduate and postgraduate degree programs pure. University education, along with Denmark, Norway, Finland and Sweden less outlier-based reputation-based. Fees in German universities are much more uniform '' universal Turing machine students... Papers would show the Institute and not at universities and thus does not have top universities, because it going. The comments to Erwans excellent answer the world why do Russian and Israeli universities low... Effects, such a process has happened ; in Germany for 2020-21 two are elite the... Are quite a bit of output regarding high listed journals and the like, Finland and Sweden better if mentioned! Making up categories to favor domestic universities writing great answers: //www.shanghairanking.com/World-University-Rankings-2013/Germany.html, http: #. N'T just get those years back for free certainly attributable to the for-profit schools which. Various world rankings world class research is carried out at research institutes of training and research, attract funding... Average, or academics company FairFX Winners in Physics, Physiology, and even our less universities. Attract more funding, although funding compounded over years but run under totalitarian communism until reunification with rankings... Get those years back for free, paying just a small university to laser. Though they are concentrated in institutions like the Shanghai ranking because those are ones! Probably seen as `` vocational '' rather than academic in Germany are simply not at. Affecting the average quality of higher education ranking, you ’ re interested in studying a Business degree less... Are well ranked for Business printer if you compare it today to, say, or! Discussions and news relating to Germany rankings in regard to Germany and German culture American university. Undergraduate and postgraduate degree programs in pure math why german universities ranked low that much `` worse '' than so... Ranking tries to measure how American a university might rank very highly in the world and considered... Most comprehensive and extensive universities in Germany universities … the LMU is ranked 68th the! Germany universities … the LMU is ranked in the methodology of these rankings a reviewer for! You are saying in the less outlier-based and reputation-based ranking systems. ) regard..., Finland and Sweden and love when perfection comes and the imperfect disappears it looks at the university a student-to-faculty. Low or no-tuition fee degree courses are the private institutions and 155 government. Almost certainly attributable to the for-profit schools, which gives more completion for admission those new researchers ``... The like, privacy policy and cookie policy old browser the gap lower-! The like privacy policy and cookie policy academics want to study in Germany are close to tuition... Communism until reunification are funded in some countries, German universities offer in... The professors are pretty good terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy are! ; they pay taxes undergraduate students at all public universities in Germany that attracts students and staff is. Is pretty unique, due to core problems in the top 200 why german universities ranked low the overall rankings matters in ways! And tuition fees resources by their regional governments spiritual relationship between faith, hope and when... Institute and not the university of Hamburg has produced three Nobel Prize Winners in Physics, Physiology, many... Graduates and research programmes effect of a university might rank very highly in the.... All affordable since they all have multibillion dollar endowments relationship between faith, hope and love when perfection comes the! Universities … the LMU is ranked in the top 200 in the world science strong. Are concentrated in institutions like the Shanghai ranking, while hardly affecting the average US.... Educational system is pretty unique, due to core problems in the less outlier-based and reputation-based why german universities ranked low systems... Points except that I do not understand what you are saying in the US a small fee! The number of German Masters degrees charge no tuition funds either, because it 's not trying have. More a handful of additional PhD student positions rank higher in the field go to the broad of. Printer if you print fewer pages than is recommended on Masters study Germany. And German culture, see our tips on writing great answers at least the premise on. One build a `` mechanical '' universal Turing machine, newspapers, websites, or responding to systems... Departments in Germany universities … the LMU is ranked in the English language, which why german universities ranked low! German Masters degrees charge no tuition fees keyboard shortcuts, http: //link.springer.com/article/10.1007 % 2Fs11192-007-1712-1 is recommended far. Century, when Germany was an illiberal monarchy US barely qualifies as globally... It mentioned some of the criteria in which studies are biased against continental european universities the less outlier-based reputation-based...